Dungeon Master lost in Forgotten Realms

This post could also have been called:

  • Forgotten Realms suck!
  • I hate Forgotten Realms
  • When and where should i set my Forgotten Realms campaign?

First, if you are new to D&D, starting with 5e, buying adventures, you will be alright! Everything is taken care of for you, just go with the flow.

Background

I played D&D 30 years ago. About 25 years ago I played AD&D 2e in Forgotten Realms. Now I am picking up D&D again, this time 5e, and I still have my Forgotten Realms 2e stuff. I create my own campaign and my own adventures so I just thought I needed to pick a date (year) and a place in Forgotten Realms and get started. Well, the internet is an amazing resource for a Dungeon Master, but the confusion is also so much bigger!

Why use Forgotten Realms at all?

I own some content for Forgotten Realms, maps and books. That is better than nothing (at least I want to think so). Drawing maps take time. And inventing deities is not my piece of cake. However, I realised that not even maps or deities are constant in Forgotten Realms, and I was confused.

The Short Version

Wizards of the Coast (who makes D&D), want the world (Forgotten Realms) to match the rules of their game. Fair enough! So when the rules change, the world changes, quite dramatically (!).

Dates of the Campaing Books/Sets for each [A]D&D version (I just copied this from somewhere, the important thing right now is not the details):

  • AD&D 1e: 1358.
  • AD&D 2e: 1368 (after Time of Troubles 1358)
  • D&D 3e: 1372
  • D&D 4e: 1479 (after Spellplague 1385)
  • D&D 5e: 1491 (after Second Sundering 1480)

These events (Time of Troubles, Spellplague, Second Sundering) are not minor or ordinary events. Thy are the kind of earth-shattering events that I’d prefer to have 2000-3000 years back (like the First Sundering).

I am not an expert (not even a novice) on Forgotten Realms Lore, but the idea here is that major changes and events happened in Forgotten Realms to match the rules of 2e, 4e and 5e. And, to simplify things a little, 5e mostly reset things to 2e (and the Spellplague was a mistake).

An example of a rules-change is the race Dragonborn, introduced in 4e and “justified” via the events of Spellplague. WotC could have pretended Dragonsborns always existed and that they were just never mentioned and there were never any rules for them. But WotC choose to create an event that explained why there were Dragonborns in 4e, but not before (and many other things).

How to get a grasp of the Lore?

I recommend the youtube series Forgotten Realms Lore by Jorphdan. Watch the first 20 episodes (!) and you will feel a lot more comfortable about a lot of things!

When to set a 5e campaign

Here are some options I came up with for when to set a 5e campaign in Forgotten Realms

  1. In the 2e-3e-era, like 1368-1375. If you dont have 2e-3e resources this probably makes little sense. And you will need to deal with cases where the rules don’t match the Lore (are there Dragonborns, and where do they come from)?
  2. In 1491 as is intended. The possible problem is that you have 100+ years of history that is very confusing and complex. Your PCs and NPCSs will have so many weird (recent) memories. This is not optimal with 2e Forgotten Realms resources.
  3. In 1491 as intended, pretending the Spellplague and the Sundering never happened. Both 2e,3e and 5e resources should be quite useful, as long as you have a basic understanding of what you are leaving out.
  4. Later, like 1550-1600, when the Second Sundering has faded from recent memory and things have stabilized (if you like that, as a DM). This is not optimal with any official Forgotten Realms resources.
  5. Any other time that you find particularly interesting!
  6. Use Alternative Forgotten Realms, for a more low level setting.
  7. Just use the maps, and cherry-pick only things that you specifically need.
  8. I am choosing to make a few hundred years of Dark Age first.

I was thinking to choose (1), since I have 2e resources. But it is not very easy either, becuase for example the article on Moonshae in the Wiki says: “This article is incomplete.It is missing 1e and 2e information, including a whole sourcebook worth of pre-Spellplague lore.

Conclusion

Forgotten Realms is a double edged resource. And the events from 1350 to 1480 (just before 5e takes place) are extreme enough that it would be better if they were serveral thousand years apart, and several thousand years ago.

Still, I think the Youtube videos I linked to help to get you onboard, and if you make a few decisions that work for your campaing, you should be quite fine. Remember that there is nothing wrong in changing whatever you want!

Leave a Comment


NOTE - You can use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.